Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Detention (Dekanalog) Blu-ray Review

Collapse
X
Collapse
  •  
    Ian Jane
    Administrator

  • Detention (Dekanalog) Blu-ray Review

    Click image for larger version

Name:	Detention-Blu-ray-Review-cover.jpg
Views:	133
Size:	18.9 KB
ID:	385688

    Released by: Dekanalog
    Released on: January 25th, 2022.
    Director: John Hsu
    Cast: Gingle Wang, Fu Meng-Po, Tse Jing-Hua, Cecilia Choi
    Year: 2019
    Purchase From Amazon

    Detention - Movie Review:

    Based on the popular Taiwanese video game of the same name, director John Hsu's 2019 film Detention is set just in the 1960's in Taiwan during the era of White Terror, a long period of very strict political oppression for the island nation.

    A high school student named Wei Chung Ting is one of a few members of a clandestine book club setup without the government's knowledge by a teacher named Miss Yin Tsui Han that gives certain students access to literature and art banned by the government. While this is very definitely illegal, the students truly appreciate it and seem to get a lot out of it. When the club is discovered, however, Wei and a few others are arrested and then tortured. This causes Wei, clearly suffering mental duress from the abuse, to enter a nightmare version of the school which is all boarded up and populated not by students but by monsters.

    Wei does run into one student, a young woman named Fang Ray Shin who has no idea how she arrived in this alternate reality version of the school. Together, they come to learn that they're trapped on the grounds and hope to find a teacher named Mr. Chang Ming Hui. Eventually they learn that the book club was discovered because someone went to the authorities to report its existence, and Wei suspects that Fang Ray Shin might have been the one responsible. She flees, and Wei learns that the other students from the book club have been executed. As this plays out, through flashbacks we learn about Ray's life in and out of the school and her complicated relationship with Mr. Chang Ming Hui and how all of this ties to the main narrative set in the alternate version of the school.

    In terms of its narrative, Detention is a mess. At times needless complicated, the movie goes in a few different directions at once and never does a satisfying job of resolving them. Having knowledge of Taiwanese history would almost certainly help with this, but the movie, not originally geared to a western audience, doesn't give us any background information here to help out. On top of this, the movie is chock full of B-grade digital effects work that make it feel more like the video game it was based on than the live action feature it's supposed to be. There's so much digital work going on here that it even results in some odd trailing and stuttering in the backgrounds. Maybe this would work for the original game's fan base but going into this blind without prior knowledge of the game, it just didn't work.

    The movie does have some merit, however. The acting is generally quite strong, with all the main members of the cast doing fine work. There's some great looking monsters and a few eerily memorable set pieces on display in the picture. The movie also has some truly excellent sound design working in its favor. Sadly, this isn't enough to save the film from its needlessly messy narrative and lackluster digital effects.

    Detention - Blu-ray Review:

    Detention comes to Blu-ray in an AVC encoded 1080p high definition transfer framed properly in the in 1.85.1 widescreen aspect taking up 21.4GBs of space on the 25GB disc. The transfer is uneven. The digitally shot picture looks nice and sharp in the lighter scenes showing very good detail, depth and color reproduction. The darker scenes, particularly those with a lot of CGI in them, don't seem to fare as well, often times looking muddy and showing some trailing.

    The only audio option on the disc is an excellent Mandarin 24-bit DTS-HD 5.1 Master Audio track and it sounds fantastic. If the film has its flaws, the sound design in the picture is very strong and this mix does a great job of bringing it to life. It's crystal clear and perfectly balanced with plenty of rear channel activity bringing you into the more active scenes. Plenty of tight, strong bass response here too. Optional subtitles are included in English only.

    Extras are comprised primarily of three featurettes, starting with Port Of Origin: Adapting Detention, a six minute piece exploring what went into adapting the video game and turning it into a movie. Interviews with the writing team and the director explain the importance of understanding the game and gaming in general, elements from the game that they needed to get right for the feature and the concept and history of White Terror and how it relates to the plot.

    The six and a half minute Return To Greenwood High: Making Detention featurette is a behind the scenes piece shot on the set during the making of the movie. It shows the cast and crew at work and gives us a nice look at the locations that were used for most of the movie.

    The nine and a half minute The Visual Effects Of Detention is, as you'd expect, a look at what went into the effects work featured in the film. It's pretty much all done digitally, and interviews and behind the scenes footage explain what went into bringing some of the digital creations from the game and turning them into digital creations in the movie.

    Rounding out the extras on the disc are a trailer, a music video, menus and chapter selection options.

    Inside the clear keepcase with the disc is a color insert booklet that contains two essays, The Ethics And Erotics Of Watching Detention by Timmy Chih-Ting Chen and Interpreting Apparitions: How Detention Taught A New Generation Of Youth About White Terror by Panos Kotzathanasis. Both offer some insight into the film and background info on the video game that inspired it.

    Detention - The Final Word:

    Detention has its moments but is bogged down by a few too many confusing elements and an overly digitized appearance. The Blu-ray from Dekanalog looks okay, if not amazing, but does feature some interesting featurettes and an absolutely killer sound mix. Your mileage may vary.

    Click on the images below for full sized The Detention Blu-ray screen caps!





























    Attached Files
      Posting comments is disabled.

    Latest Articles

    Collapse

    • Umma (Sony Pictures) Blu-ray Review
      Ian Jane
      Administrator
      by Ian Jane


      Released by: Sony Pictures
      Released on: May 24th, 2022.
      Director: Iris K. Shim
      Cast: Sandra Oh, Fivel Stewart, Dermot Mulroney, Odeya Rush, MeeWha Lee
      Year: 2022
      Purchase From Amazon

      Umma – Movie Review:

      Directed by Iris K. Shim and produced by Sam Raimi for his own Raimi Productions, 2022’a Umma (which is the Korean word for ‘mother’) stars Sandra Oh as a woman named Amanda who lives with her daughter Chris (Fivel Stewart)
      ...
      05-19-2022, 12:00 PM
    • Born To Win (Fun City Editions) Blu-ray Review
      Ian Jane
      Administrator
      by Ian Jane


      Released by: Fun City Editions
      Released on: April 26th, 2022.
      Director: Ivan Passer
      Cast: George Segal, Karen Black, Paula Prentiss, Hector Elizondo, Jay Fletcher, Robert De Niro
      Year: 1971
      Purchase From Amazon

      Born To Win – Movie Review:

      Directed by Ivan Passer shortly after he immigrated to The United States from his native country of Czechoslovakia, 1971’s Born To Win revolves around a man named J. (George Segal) who lives
      ...
      05-12-2022, 01:15 PM
    • House On The Edge Of The Park (Severin Films) Blu-ray Review
      Ian Jane
      Administrator
      by Ian Jane


      Released by: Severin Films
      Released on: March 29th, 2022.
      Director: Ruggero Deodato
      Cast: David Hess, Giovanni Lambardo Radice, Annie Belle, Christian Borromeo, Marie Claude Joseph, Lorraine De Selle, Brigitte Petronio
      Year: 1980
      Purchase From Amazon

      House On The Edge Of The Park – Movie Review:

      Directed by Ruggero Deodato hot on the heels of his infamous Cannibal Holocaust, 1980’s House On The Edge Of The Park opens with a
      ...
      05-12-2022, 12:35 PM
    • Video Murders (Culture Shock) Blu-ray Review
      Ian Jane
      Administrator
      by Ian Jane


      Released by: Culture Shock
      Released on: April 26th, 2022.
      Director: Jim McCullough Sr.
      Cast: Eric Brown, Virginia Loridans, John P. Fertitta
      Year: 1988
      Purchase From Amazon

      Video Murders – Movie Review:

      Directed by Jim McCullough Sr. from a script by his son, Jim McCullough Jr., 1988’s Video Murders, which was shot in and around Shreveport, Louisiana, is centered around a young man named David Lee Shepard (Eric Brown of Waxwo
      ...
      05-12-2022, 12:25 PM
    • Around The World With John “The Wadd” Holmes (Impulse Pictures) DVD Review
      Ian Jane
      Administrator
      by Ian Jane


      Released by: Impulse Pictures
      Released on: April 13th, 2021.
      Director: Donald U. Canard
      Cast: John Holmes, Gloria Adams, Colleen Brennan, Janice Bronson
      Year: 1975
      Purchase From Amazon

      Around The World With John “The Wadd” Holmes - Movie Review:

      “You're looking at the Golden Gate Bridge, one of the two wonders of San Francisco. The other wonder? Me, because I've got the biggest cock in the business.”

      This narrated
      ...
      05-12-2022, 12:22 PM
    • FleshEater (Vinegar Syndrome) UHD/Blu-ray Review
      Ian Jane
      Administrator
      by Ian Jane


      Released by: Vinegar Syndrome
      Released on: April 26th, 2022.
      Director: Bill Hinzman
      Cast: Bill Hinzman, John Mowod, Leslie Ann Wick, Kevin Kindlin, Bonnie Hinzman, Heidi Hinzman
      Year: 1988
      Purchase From Amazon

      FleshEater – Movie Review:

      Directed by and starring Bill ‘First Zombie’ Hinzman, 1988’s FleshEater is a low budget 16mm production shot around Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, just like George A. Romero’s original Night
      ...
      05-12-2022, 12:14 PM
    Working...
    X